|
Thank you for agreeing to referee
_____________________________________ (title) for Open
Museum Journal.
Please email your response to the editors by _________.
Your email should include, in its body-text, the recommendation that
you are making and a short written report on the paper outlining the
reasons for your decision. If you have made in-text comments on the
electronic copy of the proposed paper that you have refereed you should
attach this file; do not change the file name. Files should sent as
rich-text format.
Your report should address the following criteria:
- Quality of written expression and readability, relative to its content.
- Quality of its structure and internal coherence as a narrative or
argument.
- Quality of its contribution to scholarly knowledge in the field
of xxxxx.
- Quality of its engagement with the work on similar topics of other
scholars and practitioners
Where the proposed paper includes multimedia elements,
please also address the following criterion:
- Relevance and quality of multimedia elements to written text and
vice versa.
Please select one of the following choices and submit with you email
message:
-
Accept for publication without change or with minor
stylistic/grammatical corrections or:
-
Accept for publication with minor revisions to content
as indicated subject to editors further approval or:
-
Accept for publication with major revisions to content
as indicated subject to my further approval or;
-
Do not accept for publication recommend submission
to another journal or:
-
Do not accept for publication recommend substantial
revision and re-submission or;
-
Do not accept for publication do not recommend revision
or submission to another journal.
Please provide a report indicating reasons for your
decision and providing, where appropriate, clear indication of the changes
/ revisions that you are suggesting. In particular, any report that
recommends major or substantial revision should provide clear guidance
to the author as to the nature of and the reasons for these suggestions.
|